sind, i think basically you are right, laaf deserves a ban.
but what u did, was wrong: you abused and you didnt go the right way of handling laaf. in threat of admin usage, he stops laming. so its highly unprobable that laaf will get enough warnings on the server to be banned.
this doesnt mean that there is no way to an laaf. you have to pass it along to the counci, with a request to the hc's to check the logs.
you can be sure that we find enough stuff for laffy's ban. what you did lucy, was a sign of your temper and your rage, and not a sign of your justice and duty.